The Deliberate Agrarian Blogazine
December 2010

Looking Back...
It is New Year’s eve. A time to reflect on the past and the future. I will have some comments on the future at the end of this blogazine issue. As for the past year, my thoughts center on blessings. Perhaps it is my age... the older I get the more cognizant I am of blessings. Not that I didn't have any disappointments and difficulties in 2010, because I did, but the blessings are always foremost in my mind.

Among so many other things, I'm thankful for all the people who stop by this blog to read what I have to say. I appreciate the encouraging and inspiring feedback that I have gotten from you. Many readers here have also bought my books and the project parts I sell, and I sure do appreciate that too.


My Son Has Come Home

My Sons: James, Robert & Chaz
My oldest son, Chaz, returned from his one-year tour of duty in Korea. The picture above is him with his brothers just after getting home from the airport. It took almost 48 hours of travel time for him to get from Korea to Syracuse New York.  There was some concern that he might not get out as scheduled with the tensions running high over in that area of the world, but he’s home for a couple of weeks and he’s very glad to be back on American soil. 


Follow-Up on Home Hog Butchering
Hog Butchering Picture by Scott in Pennsylvania
In response to last month's discussion here about family hog processing, I received the picture above and the following e-mail from Scott in Pennsylvania:
Here in south central PA, family butchering is still alive, but perhaps alive and well would be an overstatement.  I'm trying to attend as many butcherings as possible to get the skills, and tools, while the info is relatively accessible and free.
And then there was there was Gina’s blog post this last month at "Home Joys".....

“Every December, my parents hold an old fashioned hog butchering at their farm. This year we butchered four hogs raised by a local farmer. The average weight of these hogs was 430 lb - much larger then a typical hog. That translates into a lot of great pork to be shared by several families in the coming year.”

Photo by Gina
It so happens that Gina’s family is also from Pennsylvania and they are Mennonites. Her excellent photo-essay shows family and friends working together to get the hog-butchering work done. Even if you don’t have an interest in hog butchering, you will find the whole story of these people working together to be inspiring and endearing. Here’s the link: Hoof to Freezer: Butcher Day 2010

Interesting Book 
With A Terrible Title

This building in Old Economy Village, Pennsylvania, is part of what remains of the nineteenth century Christian communal group known as the Harmony Society. The Harmonists were known worldwide for their piety and prosperity. Members of the society followed their founder, Georg Rapp from Germany seeking religious and economic freedoms.

A friend of mine gave me a book that he was sure I would like. This book was first published in 1875. It is titled The Communistic Societies of The United States. If I were to come across this book in a store, that title would be an instant turnoff. I have no interest in communism as it is understood these days—in the national, political sense.  But it turns out that this book isn’t about that kind of communism.

“The Communistic Societies of The United States" was written in 1875 and it is all about groups of people who voluntarily united into well-organized communal groups or societies. The Shakers, for example, were a communistic society, and they are discussed at length in a chapter of the book.

Some other communistic societies with chapters in the book are The Amana Society, The Harmony Society, The Separatists of Zoar, Wilhelm Keil's Aurora Commune and Bethel Commune, The Icarians, and The Bishop Hill Colony.

What makes this book unique and of particular interest is that its author, Charles Nordhoff, a newspaper correspondent, actually visited all these communities. He spent time studying and understanding them. For example, eighteen Shaker societies were in operation in 1874 when Nordhoff did his research, and he visited all but four of them. His book is a factual firsthand account of what he saw as an outsider looking in.

Nordhoff had a specific reason for visiting and studying these communistic societies. He felt they might offer a solution to growing labor problems in the nation. Nordhoff foresaw a significant problem developing because the cheap and fertile frontier lands of America were almost gone. 

It was the availability of unsettled farm land that had, from the beginning of American history, provided common men of no means with the opportunity to achieve independence and prosperity on their own piece of land.

When such lands were no longer there for hardworking and independent-minded people to settle, Nordhoff thought that communistic societies might provide much the same benefits of ownership and prosperity, not individually, but corporately, and not politically, but on a small, voluntary scale.

Upon learning this about Nordhoff, I immediately thought of my favorite historian, Walter Prescott Webb and his remarkable book, The Great Frontier. Webb’s book was published  77 years after Nordhoff’s. By then, all those practically-free frontier lands were gone. The Oklahoma Land Rush of 1893 pretty much marked the end of the 400-year-long era of economic boom that came with the discovery of vast new-world lands and their incredible store of new natural resources.

Professor Webb’s boom hypothesis of modern history is well worth understanding because, as I have stated here (numerous times) in the past, we today are living in a post-boom era. Unless someone discovers a new world chock full of natural resources to plunder, and amenable land for human settlement, our civilization will continue its inevitable decline from that era of historical-abberation prosperity.

The communistic societies that Charles Nordhoff visited and wrote about are now gone. They are historical curiosities. But they served their purpose for a season. In many instances, they allowed poor people with little hope for the future to join with others and work for the common good. Many of these societies were quite prosperous (though they lived simply and economically). Once established, the people lived comfortably and many lived to an old age. They were not subsidized by the government and they provided much in the way of “social services” help to the community around them.

I think we will see a resurgence of interest in these kinds of “communistic” societies in the days ahead. As economic conditions continue to decline, as standards of living fall, as local and state governments go bankrupt and government programs like Socialist Security and Medicare fade into history, as we enter a postindustrial agrarian era, it makes sense that intentional, voluntary communities of like-minded people will become more common.

Anyone with an interest in such societies would do well to read Charles Nordhoff’s book for some historical and practical perspective. Used copies can be found on the internet for a very reasonable price.

The Premise of Hirelings 

Factory-Worker Hirelings in Pink

In Charles Nordhoff’s introduction to his aforementioned book, “The Communistic Societies of the United States,” he makes some comments that really resonated with me. It would appear that in Nordhoff’s day, trade and labor unions were a force to reckon with. They supposedly served the best interests of workers, and on the one hand, this was true. In those days miners and factory workers who were being exploited were able to get better working conditions because of unions. But Nordhoff didn’t like the unions. He did not like them for a reason that I certainly never considered and I doubt you have either. I’ll let Mr. Nordhoff tell you that reason:
”The member of a Trades-Union is taught to regard himself, and act toward society, as a hireling for life; and these societies are united, not as men seeking a way to exchange dependence for independence, but as hirelings, determined to remain such, and only demanding better conditions of their masters.”
”Any organization which teaches it’s adherents to accept as inevitable for themselves and for the mass of a nation the condition of hirelings, and to conduct their lives on that premise, is not only wrong, but an injury to the community.”
Well, 135 years after those words were written “that premise” is now fully ingrained in our American culture. Very few people these days value and pursue such independence. Very few are, as Nordhoff puts it elsewhere in the book, “independent employers of their own labor.”

As I considered this situation I had to ask myself why this is. The answer I came up with is that it’s a lot easier to be a hireling. The whole industrial system, with it's onerous government regulation and taxes, coupled with inexpensive, centralized mass-production of goods by factories, along with corporate-monopoly control of markets, has done much to stifle personal initiative and force people into the hireling mold.

Bearing that in  mind, I recently heard someone (an entrepreneurial woman) state that young people shouldn’t be looking for jobs because jobs just make you lazy. Instead, young people should be entrepreneurs, looking for and working towards having their own business. This advice was directed towards a young boy with a low-paying, menial job that he hates but endures because he doesn't see any other options.

But developing an entrepreneurial mindset is totally contrary to the way our culture educates its children. Children are educated to be hirelings. After high school, they go on to college where they are further educated and directed into a job as a higher-paid (hopefully) hirelings. How many people train their children up to be independent minded entrepreneurs? Can you think of any?

Well, I happen to have one single friend who has done this. His name is Dale Weed and he owns New Hope Mills. Dale has taken the 1823 mill and business his father started in 1947 and grown it into something that his father would be amazed to see if he were still alive. Most of Dale’s children work in the family business. They are a Christian family (Dale used to be pastor of the church I attend), and they have a “family economy” (a family working together to support itself) that is rare in this day and age. It is a pleasure to behold.

Though Marlene and I have stressed the virtues of self employment and entrepreneurship, and modeled entrepreneurial activities in our family, and our children have helped us in those activities, none of them have taken to it. I'm not sure why. It might have something to do with the lack of maturity and impatience of youth. They lack focus and determination when it comes to delayed gratification, which is the kind of gratification that typically comes with an entrepreneurial venture. 

It is rare to find a truly entrepreneurial child. I suspect that most children who are lauded for a successful entrepreneurial enterprise have a hard-working parent or two doing more than meets the eye behind the scenes.

In my own instance, I've come to the conclusion that the best I can do for now is provide the entrepreneurial example, encourage my children to develop a good work ethic (even if it is as a hireling) and to encourage them to acquire marketable skills. In time, with maturity, I believe the entrepreneurial spirit will come.

Also, I'm inclined to think that imagination and creativity are essential to developing the entrepreneurial mindset. Most artistic people who make money at their art are, of necessity, entrepreneurial. 

Thinking back on my own boyhood, I can see that my Grandmother Kimball was an artistic influence in my life. She involved me in the crafts that she was doing, and bought me different kinds of craft kits to work on when I stayed with her in the summers of my childhood. If you would have creative, entrepreneurial children, it seems to me that they should be exposed to a variety of artistic and creative skills.

Before closing on this topic of hirelings and dependents vs. independent entrepreneurs, I can think of a specific group pf people in America who successfully train their children up to be independent employers of their own labor. It’s the Amish, and I suppose we could include the Mennonites too. Not all of these people are self employed but I’m certain that a significantly greater proportion of them are self employed, as compared to the rest of the culture around them. I suspect that a great measure of this success comes from teaching their children how to work....

Teaching Children to Work

In last month’s blogazine edition I talked about the ages-old way that young boys learned to be men and do the work of men. They did it by doing the work of farming and trades along with their fathers and other men of the community, starting from a very young age. The Amish are an excellent modern-day example of this. It would appear (from Gina’s hog butchering story above) that the Mennonites are too.

This thought was reinforced in my understanding a couple weeks ago when I happened upon a free internet movie about the Amish. I think this movie is probably the best thing you could watch to learn about and understand the Old Order Amish culture. The film was made in 1975 and it is 54 minutes long (and free to watch). I recommend it to you. Here is the link: The Amish: A People of Preservation.

If you watch that film you will see young children working and helping in the important work of the family farm. You will see entire families working together. One segment shows a boy maybe six years old driving two large draft horses pulling a piece of farm equipment. Here are some quotes from the movie
”Shared within the family, hard work becomes a seasonal ritual.”
”Work, under the right circumstances, is as enjoyable as play. Shared work is, in many cases, the Amishman’s recreation.”
”The child learns to work primarily by imitation. He learns to respect work because it’s close to shameful to be lazy.”
”[A boy] begins to work as soon as he is physically capable. You ask him to gather the eggs as soon as he is able to carry a basket out into the chicken house. He is taught to have responsibility.”
”Then as you grow older, you get more and more responsibility. And then eventually you get to the place where you can do the chores so that if Dad is gone, he doesn’t have to worry about being at home on time. It’s very serious to accept your responsibilities and fulfill them.”
”The Amish find their happiness and meaning in labor, rather than escape from it.”
It appears to me that when young boys are given responsibility they are faced with problems and situations that require them to come up with their own solutions. In so doing, they exercise their imagination and learn self-reliance. Such self-reliance brings confidence. And, of course, doing their work brings a well-developed sense of self worth.

My Story

That boy is not me, but close enough. I used to wear gloves just like that when handling hay bales on the farm.

I did not grow up in an Amish environment. My stepfather was an insurance salesman, working out of his car, driving to appointments every day. The suburban neighborhood I lived in until half way through ninth grade was full of fathers who left their home each morning for industrial jobs (fortunately, most mothers were still at home back then). This situation left me and all the boys I knew with little to do but try to amuse ourselves. We didn’t have electronic games and cell phones and all of that back then. We watched television. We played some informal sports. And we did a lot of things we shouldn’t have been doing. It was not an environment conducive to raising boys to be productive (or independent) men. Not at all. Juvenile delinquents, yes. Productive, capable men, no.

Then, by the grace of God, my parents bought an old farm house out in the rural countryside. It was in an agricultural community. I had a chance to see farmers doing work, and when the haying season came around, I had work to do, helping a local farmer and his three sons get the hay crop in. Unloading hay wagons and packing the bales into the barn is man’s work. I watched and learned and helped. Helping and learning from men doing the hard work of farming had a profound impact on me.

A mile or so up the road from our house there lived a man who did mechanic work. His garage was literally attached to his house. The farmer I worked for had this mechanic do some of his repairs (I say “some” because the farmer was very capable and resourceful when it came to doing his own repairs). I learned that there was little that this mechanic could not do. I looked up to him because he was so incredibly capable with his hands. He could build anything. He could fix anything. And he had learned much of what he knew working with his father who was a self-employed boat mechanic and owned a marina on a nearby lake.

The mechanic was independent minded. So were the farmers. The rural countryside of America is full of people like that. 

Once I got out of suburbia into the countryside I was exposed to one hardworking, independent-minded male role model after another. Many of these men happened to be Christians. Theirs was a powerful example to me at a time in my life when I was really looking for my identity. I did not look to my peers, or sports “heroes,” or movie and rock stars for role models. My role models were the rural men I knew and worked with.

Oh, I will admit that I was an admirer of Ralph Waite as John Walton on "The Walton’s" television program. And of Michael Landon as Pa Ingalls on the "Little House on The Prairie" program, but that’s because those men were like the men I knew and admired in real life.

John & Olivia Walton from "The Waltons" Television Program (1972—1981). As a teenager, I admired John Walton. Does television have such wholesome role models today? I wouldn't know because I don't watch television anymore.
Boys need good role models at an impressionable age. I was blessed to be in an environment, and to take a path, that exposed me to some very decent role models.

In my senior year of high school I worked at New Hope Mills every day after school and on vacations, packing pancake mix into bags for Dale Weed’s father, Leland, a remarkable man who was certainly an independent-minded entrepreneur. 

In time, I worked full time on a dairy farm for one year. I also worked for one summer with another independent-minded, resourceful, self-employed man cutting pulpwood and spray painting bars. Then I went into the building trades and got a chance to work closely with other men building and remodeling. Carpenters, roofers, masons, drywallers, plumbers—all kinds of capable, resourceful, independent-minded craftsmen—were my examples and mentors.

So that’s my story (you can read an expanded version At This Link). If I had never moved from the housing project, none of this would have happened. I probably would have gone on to college and become a doctor. That was my aim in life from a kid right up to ninth grade. Nothing against doctors, but I’m a whole lot more satisfied with the path I took.


Boys to Men

"Farm Boy And Horse Team Loading Hay" by Victor C Anderson (1882-1937)

So then the question arouse.... what about my own boys? How will they get a chance to work with men and, hopefully, develop manly skills and confidence? 

The ideal situation would have been for me to have a farm, but that was beyond my ability. So Marlene and I chose a deliberate agrarian lifestyle. We lived in the country. We grew our own food. We homeschooled our kids (more about this shortly). We worked together as a family doing things like making maple syrup, and getting the firewood ready for winter, and butchering chickens. When I worked in my workshop, my kids had access to the shop and the tools and the scraps of wood to work with. We did the best we could with the resources we had to model and teach the goodness of hard work associated with self reliance.

My two youngest sons took to all of this exceptionally well. When they were maybe 11 or 12 years old they had an opportunity to help a nearby dairy farmer pick stones from his fields before planting in the springtime. This farmer and his grown son, both Christian men, asked lots of boys from their rural church to help with the stone picking. Picking stones in the hot sun is hard, dirty work but when you got a bunch of your friends all working together, the work is almost fun, just like they said in the Amish movie quote above.

In time my two sons had the opportunity to help with hay and chores and other tasks on that farm, then on other farms. It turns out that opportunities come to children who have a good work ethic.

Another neighboring farmer took James under his wing. He has taught James all about so many aspects of farming and animal husbandry and machine operation. Robert, got a job working for a contractor who has an extensive maple syrup operation on the side. He has gotten all kinds of hands-on experience working with men to do skilled, productive, hard work.

This picture of my sons, James & Robert was taken 4+ years ago. You can read the story that goes with the picture at my essay titled, Hay Hooks.

It’s not the Amish experience, but it’s akin to it, and I feel my boys are all the better for it. I dare say, this sort of thing rarely happens outside of a rural/agrarian setting.

I know there are plenty of men who read this blog that were blessed with farm work in the country when they were boys—work that helped shape who they are. And, looking back, these men understand the value of their rural upbringing. But there are others who read this blog and see the wisdom of this but can’t seem to figure out how their young sons will be able to transition properly into manhood because the dominant popular culture has redefined manhood for boys— it strives to feminize boys and turn them into immature, self-centered, materialistic men who are virtually helpless when it comes to manual work and manual skills.

I’m no child psychologist, and God knows I’m not the best example of a father, and I in no way claim to be an expert on raising children, but I know firsthand the wholesome, positive influence that a rural-based, self-reliant family lifestyle can have on a boy (as compared to the urban/suburban lifestyle). 

The Homeschooling Factor 
(And The Amish)
An Amish school in Middlefield, Ohio. The Amish have won the right to school their own children as they wish and do not have to send them to government schools. Do you think they are able to give their children a decent education for less money than the government school system? You better believe it!
It occurs to me that, even living in the country, my sons would never have had all the opportunities they have had to work with  men doing men’s work if they went to a government school. And, probably, had they gone to the government school, they wouldn’t have been interested in doing the work they have done.

Those boys my son worked with when helping the dairy farmer pick rocks were all homeschoolers. They picked rocks when other kids were sitting in a classroom. Same goes with loading hay trucks in the winter months. It’s hard to find boys to help load a hay truck when school is in session, but it’s no problem when those boys are homeschoolers. James has gone numerous times with his farmer/mentor in the farmer's truck to deliver big loads of hay, and been gone all day on a school day. Marlene was concerned about him not doing his schooling but I told her it was okay—James was learning things those kids in government school will never have a chance to learn. That is part of the beauty of homeschooling.

Which brings me back to the Amish... The Amish don’t have to send their kids to government school. In 1972 they won a landmark supreme court case that allowed them to take care of schooling their own children. Supreme court justice Warren Burger wrote the following in response to the government’s argument that the Amish were wrong in their approach to educating their children:
”There can be no assumption that today’s majority is right and the Amish and others like them are wrong. A way of life that is odd or even erratic but interferes with no rights or interests of others is not to be condemned because it is different.”
What’s different about Amish schooling is that Amish kids are educated only to the eighth grade, and their Amish teachers have only an eighth grade education. There is no high school and there is no college for Amish children. To the typical Modern American the thought of educating children only to 13 or 14 years old is something like child abuse. But I dare say that government schooling is more child abuse than Amish schooling.

Which brings me to John Taylor Gatto. No one can condemn government schooling as well as John Taylor Gatto. He was in the system, distinguished himself as a remarkably effective educator, realized the great evil of it, got out, and has been sounding the alarm ever since.

In one YouTube movie I watched, Gatto makes the point that in the 1850’s virtually everyone in America had an independent livelihood. They were farmers or craftsmen—capable, self-reliant, resourceful men (and women). This era was, by the way, the era in which Charles Nordhoff lived.

John Taylor Gatto 
On Modern Education

Government-Schooled Boys Getting An Education

If you are not familiar with John Taylor Gatto, do yourself a favor and read his article that was in Harper's magazine:  Against School: How Public Education Cripples Our Kids And Why. Gatto has written whole books about the dangers of the government education system, but that magazine article is a concise summation of his insights. Here are a few choice quotes (but, really, read that article):
By the time I finally retired in 1991, I had more than enough reason to think of our schools—with their long-term, cell-block-style, forced confinement of both students and teachers—as virtual factories of childishness
We have, for example, the great H. L. Mencken, who wrote in The American Mercury for April 1924 that the aim of public education is not...

“to fill the young of the species with knowledge and awaken their intelligence. ...Nothing could be further from the truth. The aim ... is simply to reduce as many individuals as possible to the same safe level, to breed and train a standardized citizenry, to put down dissent and originality. That is its aim in the United States... and that is its aim everywhere else.”
Gatto explains that our current educational system was intentionally modeled after the Prussian educational system. This Prussian system created “a population deliberately dumbed down and declawed in order that government might proceed unchallenged and corporations might never want for obedient labor.”
There were vast fortunes to be made, after all, in an economy based on mass production and organized to favor the large corporation rather than the small business or the family farm. But mass production required mass consumption, and at the turn of the twentieth century most Americans considered it both unnatural and unwise to buy things they didn’t actually need. Mandatory schooling was a godsend on that count. School didn’t have to train kids in any direct sense to think they should consume nonstop, because it did something even better: it encouraged them not to think at all. And that left them sitting ducks for another great invention of the modern era—marketing
Now, you needn’t have studied marketing to know that there are two groups of people who can always be convinced to consume more than they need to: addicts and children. School has done a pretty good job of turning our children into addicts, but it has done a spectacular job of turning our children into children. Again, this is no accident. Theorists from Plato to Rousseau to our own Dr. Inglis knew that if children could be cloistered with other children, stripped of responsibility and independence, encouraged to develop only the trivializing emotions of greed, envy, jealousy, and fear, they would grow older but never truly grow up.
Now for the good news. Once you understand the logic behind modern schooling, its tricks and traps are fairly easy to avoid. School trains children to be employees and consumers; teach your own to be leaders and adventurers. School trains children to obey reflexively; teach your own to think critically and independently. Well-schooled kids have a low threshold for boredom; help your own develop an inner life so that they’ll never be bored. Urge them to take on the serious material, the grown-up material, in history, literature, philosophy, music, art, economics, theology—all the stuff schoolteachers know well enough to avoid. Challenge your kids with plenty of solitude so that they can learn to enjoy their own company, to conduct inner dialogues. Well-schooled people are conditioned to dread being alone, and they seek constant companionship through the TV, the computer, the cell phone, and through shallow friendships quickly acquired and quickly abandoned. Your children should have a more meaningful life, and they can.
You can learn more about the work of John Taylor Gatto at his web site: the Odysseus Group: Challenging The Myths of Modern Schooling


This is Our Slaughterhouse

This picture is not directly related to the story below.  I just like it, and it comes from an essay titled, Chicken Butchering 2010, at the (not so) Urban Hennery

Speaking of resourceful, self-reliant, imaginative, hard working people, self-employment, the family economy, and rural life, it was my great pleasure to discover a neat little (22 minute) movie on the internet titled, This Is Our Slaughterhouse.

The Boerman family processes poultry for themselves and people in their community every weekend. The whole family and several friends work together. It’s a beautiful thing to see, and I especially like the movie because I’m fascinated by the subject of poultry butchering.

If there was a poultry slaughterhouse like this movie shows in my community, people for miles around would come to it. I suspect that such places are few and far between (I know of none anywhere in central New York state) because of the onerous government regulations that come into play.

The movie was made in 2000. I e-mailed Matthew Boerman to ask if his family’s poultry butchering business was still in operation. The good news is that they are still at it.

Kudos to the Boerman family!

What About 
The Amish Community?
I find it curious that Charles Nordhoff, in his study of “communistic societies” back in 1874, did not mention the Amish. They came to America in the 1700’s to escape persecution in Switzerland. Though the Amish are not communistic in the sense that they hold all property in common, they do have a very close community that helps each other, and they are united by well-ordered rules and their religious faith.

The Old Order Amish Wikipedia link says that...
“From 1992 to 2008, population growth among the Amish in North America was 84%. During that time they established 184 new settlements and moved into six new states. In 2000, approximately 165,620 Old Order Amish resided in the United States, of which 73,609 were church members The Amish are among the fastest-growing populations in the world, with an average of 6.8 children per family.”
I'm glad to see the population of "plain people" is going up. I'm sure that anyone looking to establish an "intentional community" in this day and age can learn more from the Amish example than they can from the failed Utopian communities that Charles Nordhoff wrote about in 1875 (but the Nordhoff book is still useful in many respects).

The Great Shaker Barn 
of Mount Lebanon

This Shaker-built barn was once the largest barn in America

In reading the Nordhoff book mentioned above, I found this excerpt:
As you drive up the road from Lebanon Springs, the first building belonging to the Shaker settlement which meets your eye is the enormous barn of the North Family, said to be the largest in the three or four states which near here come together, as in its interior arrangements it is one of the most complete. This huge structure lies on a hillside, and is two hundred and ninety-six feet long by fifty feet wide, and five stories high, the upper story being on the level with the main road, and the lower opening on the fields behind it.
I wondered if this barn was still standing and did a Google search. Here is what remains today after a fire in 1972:

Plans are in order to restore this barn to its former beauty. I'd like to see that.

Shaker Faith
This Shaker woman is Eldress Anna. Eldress Anna gives me the creeps.  Eldress Anna reminds me of a character from the original Star Trek television program I used to watch when I was a suburban kid. But that was fiction and Eldress Anna was real!

What I like about the Shakers was their example of agrarian lifestyle, simplicity, economy, order, and hand-craftsmanship. Their buildings and furniture are beautiful. Unfortunately their faith was nothing short of weird.

The Shakers called themselves “The United Society of Believers in Christ’s Second Appearing” which sounds like some sort of Christian denomination. But their belief system was not Christian and Charles Nordhoff in his Communistic Societies book makes this very clear:
”They reject the doctrine of the Trinity, of the bodily resurrection, and of an atonement for sins. They do not worship either Jesus or Ann Lee, holding both to be simply elders in the church, to be respected and loved.”
(Ann Lee was the founder of the church and died in the 1700’s.)

The Shakers did not accept the most central and fundamental doctrines of the Bible (a book they referred to but rarely read). Instead they were avid Spiritualists who sought guidance from the spirit world through mediums and clairvoyants in their midst. Nordhoff presents excerpts from a book written by a Shaker man in which he tells of some bizarre experiences with the spirit world. Clearly (to me, at least) the spirits were demonic.

So, as much as I admire the Shaker work ethic and lifestyle and craftsmanship, I am profoundly disappointed with their religion.


Exploring Folkstreams
Tinsmithing was once a necessary craft. Then came the factory-made tin goods, and now we have plastic—lots of plastic—and tinsmithing is a "folk craft." CLICK HERE to see a movie of a tinsmith at work.
If you go to the previous links I gave you for the Amish movie and "This is Our Slaughterhouse" movie, you’ll find that they are on a web site called Folkstreams, which has quite a collection of interesting documentary movies, all free for the watching.

I especially like the movie clips in which elderly craftsmen are making something using old tools and techniques. One such movie is Ben’s Mill: Making a Sled. This 26 minute movie is described like this: “Ben Thresher's mill is one of the few water-powered, woodworking mills left in this country. Operating in rural Vermont since 1848, the mill is a unique link between the age of craft and the age of modern industry.”

I’ll never make a horse-drawn sled for hauling logs but that is beside the point. The man in the movie is a multitalented, resourceful craftsman like was once so commonly found in rural New England.

If you like that movie, there is another movie on YouTube showing Ben Thresher making a sod lifter and a round wood stock watering tub. CLICK HERE to see the movie.

Another fine film clip is Alex Stewart: Cooper. The 11 minute film is described as follows: “A 1973 film of Alex Stewart, a mountain craftsman from near Sneedville, Tennessee, constructing a churn.  Film includes discussion of the use of non-powered tools and skills handed down in Stewart's family in making wooden containers, such as buckets and barrels. “

Mr. Stewart, 83 years old, learned the coopering trade from his father, who learned it from his father before him. What is remarkable is that this man supported a wife and nine children on the income from farming and coopering. And his workshop is remarkable for its simplicity. 

If you have an interest in different cultures and old ways, I encourage you to visit the entire list of movies, all of which can be watched for free online, at this link:  Folkstreams Movie List

Looking Ahead 2011

I don't own a television so I didn't watch the recent 60 Minutes program about the coming crisis in the municipal bond market. But I heard about it at my December town board meeting and looked it up on the internet. You can (and should) read about it because it's going to affect you. Details and the 15-minute program segment are at THIS LINK.

It is a sobering economic prognosis we Americans are faced with. Even now, our economy is in a slow motion, years-long train wreck. The train is still moving, with cars crunching up, jumping the track, and rolling over. It will get worse before it comes to a stop. At this point there is no holding back the inertia of the credit crisis—we can only watch and try to keep out of the way.

I have a satellite radio in my workshop and sometimes I listen to the Glenn Beck show in the afternoons. The more I hear the man, the more I like him. On a recent program he repeatedly said that our economic system was "in the crapper" and there is nothing we can do about changing that reality. His concern seems to be that Americans will keep their wits about them as the economic crash intensifies.

Glenn Beck understands that great economic crisis, coupled with a large population of people dependent on government support, is the recipe for violent revolution and the loss of individual liberty. Masses of people unable to accept responsibility for meeting their own needs may willingly give up their freedom to a despotic individual or system of governance if that entity promises to alleviate their suffering. This is when our constitutional republic will face the greatest danger in its history.

I'm not sure, however, if Mr. Beck understands that when our American form of government was originally established, we were a nation of independent farmers—we were an agrarian nation—and that our constitutional system is best supported and preserved by a self-reliant agrarian population.

Thomas Jefferson knew this, as did most other founders, and I have discussed this very important (but largely ignored) point in my essay titled, The Jeffersonian Solution.

I applaud Glenn Beck for his efforts to educate and encourage his large audience to be aware of our situation, to humbly pray for God's help, to be prepared for what we face, and to never trade the blessings of our constitutional republic (individual liberty, primarily) for any other form of government.

My only concern is that he is missing the agrarian connection. It is implied in some of the monologues I've heard but I've never heard it specifically addressed. Perhaps Glenn could do a show on Thomas Jefferson's agrarian vision for America, and explain why Jefferson thought that an agrarian nation (where the greater portion of people live on the land and draw their sustenance from it) was the surest support of republican government. Then maybe he could present an economic self defense plan like I outlined back in 2008 (Read it Here). Then his detractors will really think he's crazy. God bless Glen Beck.

My Big 2011 Project

Starting in January 2011 (tomorrow) I will begin the process of producing another book. I have authored 11 books so far and self-published the last 8. There are few things in life that I enjoy more than self-publishing my own books. 

This particular book has been on my  mind for a few years. I have written and re-written the Introduction a few times. That's where it starts for me with a book—the Introduction serves to explain what the focus and intent of the book is. Then comes an outline, and I'm on my way.

Developing the idea for a new book is the fun part. Then one must get started, and that is much harder. Once started, the task soon becomes a burden, especially when there are so many other competing concerns. Finishing the project becomes something of an obsession. That has been my experience in the past. Maybe this time will be different. In fact, it might be different because this particular book is going to be something different for me.

My goal is to have this book done and to the printer by the end of February. I may not achieve that goal, but every author must have a completion date to shoot for. Thus, the next couple of blogazine issues here may be shorter than usual.

I have not given you any specific details about the book because I don't like to do that until it is well along and, preferably, ready to hand off to the printer. But I will tell you that the focus is most definitely agrarian. The book should be of interest to small-scale, sustainable farmers and serious gardeners, as well as all manner of homesteaders. My book will be historical, informative, entertaining and of practical value. To some extent, it will be a how-to book. As far as I know, there is no other book quite like it. 

Lord willing, I will complete the book and when I hand it off to the printer I will tell you all about it. I will also offer it to readers here at a reduced, pre-publication price. Stay tuned.

My Overall Plan 
For The New Year

I have an overall plan for the new year. It’s the same plan I had for last year. It seems to work well for me. It’s found in 1 Thessalonians 4:11-12

Make it your ambition to lead a quiet life, to mind your own business and to work with your hands, just as we told you, so that your daily life may win the respect of outsiders and so that you will not be dependent on anybody.

Those words come from the apostle Paul. He didn’t advise the Christians in Thessalonica to be popular “movers and shakers” in their society. He didn’t tell them they should strive for riches and power and acclaim. He told them they should live quietly and work with their hands, providing for their own needs, so as not to be dependent on others. This is a call to humility, simplicity and physical work. Such a call is totally contrary to the spirit of our age.

This calling for Christians is in accord with another bit of advice from Paul, this time to the Christians at Corinth (2 Corinthians 6:17):

Wherefore come out from among them, and be ye separate, saith the Lord, and touch not the unclean thing.

Both verses speak of  cultural separation or, as I’ve otherwise heard it put, cultural secession. This is a challenge in a world in which conformity is expected, and dependency on the worldly industrial system is encouraged. All industrial-world assumptions come into question.

Such separation is a deliberate, step by step process. And so, in this new year I hope to continue the process, I wouldn’t call that a New Year’s resolution. It’s just a renewed commitment to continue on a path that I see as wise and full of truth.

Here's wishing you and yours a safe, healthy and blessed year in 2011.


Anonymous said...

While the Shakers and Glenn Beck may have said or done some admirable things, one thing they also have in common is that they weren't and aren't Christians. Despite Glenn Beck "humbly praying for God's help" he is a Mormon and like the Shakers unfortunately not a follower of the God of the bible.

IslandHome said...

Thank you for another thought provoking and information filled blogazine - I found your blog during the year and have thoroughly enjoyed it. All the best for a great New Year, can't wait to hear more about your book.

KBCraig said...

I'm a very new follower of your blog, having found it by searching for the proper techniques for slaughtering and butchering swine and poultry.

I like what I see, and I'll continue to read what you write.

Herrick Kimball said...

Thanks for the comment about Glenn Beck.

Anyone who knows Jesus Christ as their Lord, and understands the Biblical definition of a Christian, and who has listened to Glenn Beck much can figure out pretty quick that he is not a true follower of Jesus Christ.

I chose not to make an issue of this in my blog because it is completely beside the point of what I was trying to say.

I understand that a lot of Christian ministries are critical of Glenn because of his Mormon beliefs and that's fine. But I don't think it's right to throw the baby out with the bath water.

The way I see it, the admirable things he is doing in regards to informing and warning people about the failing economy and the evils of big government are still admirable things, they are worth noting, and they are worth serious consideration, regardless of his Mormonism (which I have never heard him overtly promote).

And from my Christian perspective, humbly praying for God's help is wise and correct advice.

Thanks for the positive feedback!

A lot of people find their way to this blog via the poultry-related essays I've posted. It's good to have you as a reader.

Robert said...

Thank you for sharing the movie links. I look forward to watching them. I'm eager to see that book you're writing, too. Merry Christmas and a happy New Year.

Kavius said...

My wife and I were discussing your comments about the Amish not being included in the list of Commune based groups. This actually makes sense to us. The following comments come from reading about the Amish, not personal experience with the Amish.

Among the Amish, while there is a strong sense of community, they tend to be highly independent of one another. While they have a strong sense of co-operation, each family unit operates independently from one another.

I have dealt with Hutterite communes and I would not fit in to the Hutterite lifestyle. From what I have read, I think I would get along, and see eye-to-eye for the most part, with an Amish family.

Carla Hays said...


I agree totally with your thoughts on Glenn Beck. He's wise in many ways, and is causing people to think twice about believing all that mainstream media reports. His religious tenets are beside the point, and like you said, he doesn't dwell on them at all. His religious beliefs are between him and God.

As for the Pennsylvania settlement and the Harmonists, it got me to thinking about New Harmony, IN - a quaint little historic village about two hours away from us here in Southern Illinois. I have visited it, but wasn't sure of its origins, as it's been many years. I looked it up, and it is directly related to the Separatists that you mentioned in your post. I hope to go again, armed with new knowledge of exactly what they believed and settled there for. Thanks, as always, for your post. Glad Chaz is home safe and sound for a visit. He will be in my prayers, as will you, Marlene and the other boys. Happy New Year to your wonderful family. I loved Marlene's soaps and plan to buy more. They were greatly appreciated. I tucked them in with other gifts, and also printed a copy of her description to wrap each one in. :)


Anonymous said...

Just read about your son returning from Korea. It is nice he came back safely and in such a short time. Our government decided that presence in that country was needed twice in my 10 year career and the last time I came home from there to a wife and young son eagerly awaiting me it took a long tedious 17 days stopping at virtually every island in the Pacific between Inchon Korea and Oakland CAlifornia in cluding Johnson Island North and West of Hawaii. Harold Dean

Anonymous said...

After reading you entire column, I just want to comment on the stories of the Amish. Firstly, they are a group that splintered off from the Mennonites because they felt the Mennonites were becoming too "worldly". Secondly, while not Amish, but being born and raised withing an Amish community in Central Illinois, I would like to remind you that each and every community in whatever state they are located in may have different habits,ways of looking at things, etc that you can not attribute to all of the Amish like so so called historians or experts claim. The largest gathering of the Old Order Amish is in the Holmes County are of Ohio, not Pennsylvania. Our community of Arthur Illinois was established in 1865 and at one time was the only Illinois community,. Now there are several more that have taken root, some of them quite small. It takes approximately 20 families to form a church group and a new community. At 72, I feel I am quite knowledgeable enough to be able to comment on this fact as I have in my travels taking families around and being accepted as one of them I have seen the differences between communities in Ohio, Indiana, Pennsylvania, Missouri, Iowa, Kentucky, Tennessee and Maryland. Further, I do not like to be anonymous and make it seem like I am hiding, but I refuse to become associated with google or G mail since I don't approve of their ethics. Harold Dean

Anonymous said...

Mr. Kimball,
I admire your tenets and beliefs, as they are very similar to mine. I have been struggling with a means of providing for my family in the lifestyle you live. As a novice carpenter and "wanna-be" knife maker, I long to live the agrarian homestead life. My wife has also expressed a reasonable desire as well. We have a friend whose sister and brother-in-law started homesteading two years ago in Oklahoma. We have talked about selling our house in Texas and buying land near theirs, but the economy has hindered that plan severely. I have been in construction my entire career, starting out at the bottom as a laborer and eventually managing an engineering firms north Texas office. Due to a soft construction market, our firm has had to make drastic measures. I decided to change careers and now work in the oil/ gas field. It takes me away from my family but is providing for my family in a way I could never have done before. In all of this, my dilemma is that I long to raise my sons (we have three) the way you have raised yours. How can we become reformed and leave the trappings of what we have all become so accustomed to? I would give anything to worship, live and work in an agrarian homestead.
I recently found your blogazine and know that you are an inspiration to others seeking this lifestyle in these Untied States of America. I hope to find the answer to my quest in some of your writings.
Richard Emerson

Ryan said...

For an example of one of the few Christian communistic societies around today, check out It used to be called Bruderhof, and I think they may be related to the Hutterites.

Kelle said...

Thank you for another thought provoking article. The links are wonderful and we really appreciate your sharing them with us, as we don't have time to look for such things, but do enjoy watching them in the evenings.

As you have wonderful influences from your grandparents, I think our desire to live a more frugal, God reliant, lifestyle came exactly from God. Although both Mike's parents as well as my own raised small flocks of poultry and maybe even a steer or two for beef, neither were involved in growing their own foods as a chosen lifestyle, but rather because that is what everyone one was doing back in the late 60's and 70's during the energy crisis. My parent survived this period of time by opening a wood stove store and sold and installed wood stoves, as well as for some of the more crunch periods we harvested trees( lodge pole pine) from the forest service, split, stacked and cured the wood all Spring and Summer and then sold firewood by the cord( and I'm talking a true cord, not a rick, like most firewood dealers in our area try to pass off as a cord) My Dad took pride in giving people what they paid for and it came stacked, nice and neat. :o)

Thank you again for another good article, We're going to go back and watch some of the links you shared, since it's New Years Day and it's -35F with the windchill outside< Brrrrr...> It's nice and toasty inside thanks to our wood cook stove and our well seasoned firewood. *wink*

Blessings to you and your family this New Year,
Mike and Kelle

Ryan said...

In doing a little research, it seems that the Bruderhof I posted about above is considered a cult by many people. I can't be sure that it is, but it seems likely to me based on some of what I've read.

Emma said...

Thanks so much for another great read. Our family enjoys sitting down while mom reads "Mr. Chicken Plucker's" post. We have 9 children and most of them really look forward to your monthly update. (most meaning, the ones age 4 and up :)) I have never left a comment, but I felt compelled. We live near Amish and they are well...interesting. Not always upright or just. Very, very hardworking, industrious etc...Just for some info, I would suggest you look up "Trouble in Paradise" on YouTube. We just recently watched it and were shocked. We have lived near Amish all our life and never realized the spiritual vacume they live in. This film reveals that Old Order Amish are not permitted to read "english" bibles and are almost completely ignorant of any scripture. The picture in my mind has always been of a large Amish family sitting around going over the Word. No. Quite a revealing film...Keep the Amish and their salvation in your prayers. Again, thanks for a great post, we savor every issue.

Anonymous said...

I love your website and think that the best way for this country to get back to the greatness we have had is to become more self reliant. but you need to learn more about the Mormon faith don't rely on other people for your info go to the source will tell you everything about their belief and correct many misconceptions people have. I have lived among Mormons most of my life and the belief that they are not christian is propagated by people who have never looked at the religion at all. The name of the church should tell you something about their belief The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints not Mormon, Mormon is a nickname.

Anonymous said...

Dear Mr. Kimball:

Waht a joy to come across your blog. I have recently lost my father, and, after finishing a Doctorate in an esoteric field, find (at 55) I am now 'legit,' but also 'too old' to find that 'plum job' in a market where my race and ethnicity and sex(!) i.e., White American Male, are ALL against me!

Because of the $ale of my dad's home in Southern California, I am able to find that 'dream farm' with a small bit of acreage, and pay CASH- nothing fancy, but definitely not bottom of the barrel.. and with the market being the way it is, 12-15 acres homes for under 200k are out there in my part of the upper Midwest.

Trouble is, the wife and kids are rather comfortable suburbanites! The thought of owning (and living off of!) chickens and a 'family cow' (or three- gotta have that hamburger, you know!) is 'udderly foreign' to any of our upbringings, short of 'Old MacDonald' sung when the kids were 4-5.

Though I've homeschooled them for three of the last five years (dealing with dad in Cal, selling his house, and finishing the dissertation 1000 miles away, kinda puts a damper on homeschooling!) and my son wants to be homeschooled again... :-)

we're a looong way from self-sufficiency, and the psychological freedom to enable us to 'step out' and not be dependent for one person to pull home a paycheck every two weeks as a 'state employee,' if you get my drift. (wife's a school teacher, ready to retire- but, as she says, "I've got a few good years left in me.")

Do you think that (in future posts) you could detail how one 'lives off the land' - whether or not, a 'city job' is necessary, and how 'tight to the wire' one must live with the Almighty Dollar, even when being (somewhat) self-sufficient on a family farm, especially when all the skills you have are useless things like 'book larnin' and classical music backgrounds?

- HSDadPhD

Gina said...

Thanks for sharing the link to my post on our family butchering. It is fun to hear from so many that are interested in the "old ways".

As always, I enjoy your monthly post.

Anonymous said...

I know that you didn't want to get side-tracked by Beck's mormonism, but...

Martin Luther is often quoted as having said "Better to be ruled by a good Turk than a bad Christian." I similarly believe that someone can add constructively to the discussion and be a productive member of society without being a Christian. Glenn Beck evidently has a lot of common sense things to say, and for that, I think one can admire him, and "follow" him, as an individual.

But, when it comes to his religious beliefs, we have to be careful not to buy into the LDS lie that they are a Christian organization, simply because they use the same terminology that we do. The fact that Beck urges people to "humbly pray to God" is not a good thing, because the god that he is praying is no less a fabric of human imagination, and an affront to the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, than the god of Islam or any other false religion.

Thank you for your blog. I loved reading your book last year, and look forward to your blog each month. I'll also check our Glenn Beck's writings, as you have peaked my interest.

Herrick Kimball said...

You're welcome. Thank you.

That strong sense of community and co-operation is the most endearing aspect of the Amish culture, at least to my way of thinking.

Glad you liked the soaps and thank you for the prayers. The Nordhoff book does mention the Indiana Harmonist settlement.

Wow. 17 days sounds terrible! I guess 48 hours wasn't as bad as it could have been.

As for the Amish, I find it fascinating that they are spreading out and establishing communities. They have moved into my area of NY in just the past few years. And my grandfather's farm in northern Maine was purchased by one of the first Amish families to settle in that area, only a couple years ago.

In reading The Budget newspaper (published for the Amish & Mennonites across the US) it is clear that they are, like pioneers of old, heading out in groups to establish new settlements.

Hi Richard—
Yours is the common conundrum among men who realize they are caught in the industrial system vortex. I can relate. It truly is a quest to get home and establish a homestead and a home economy and live life closer to the way it should be lived. I will endeavor to put some thoughts together on this subject for an upcoming blogazine entry. Thanks for the comment.

I'll look into the Hutterites someday. I've heard of them but they are not in Nordhoff's book. As for being a cult, I think many of the religious communities Nordhoff studied were cult-like.

I enjoyed reading your comment here. There isn't a doubt in my mind that your desire to "live a more frugal, God reliant, lifestyle came exactly from God." Anyone who takes their Christianity seriously—as I gather you do— will see that frugality and God-reliance are entirely biblical. I think those who are finding and pursuing the Christian-agrarian path today are being led to it by God. And He is such an incredible orchestrator that he can do this in different lives using different influences, even over the course of many years. Awesome, eh?

Thanks for the YouTube movie suggestion. I will watch it soon.
Tell the kids that "Mr. Chicken Plucker" says, "Hi"

Herrick Kimball said...

I appreciate your comment and expected someone to make the point you have. Years ago I spent some time looking into Mormon beliefs. I have Mormon kin on my mother's side of the family, and have been asked more than once if I am related to the 12th Mormon president, Spencer W. Kimball (I am not, at least not that I am aware of).

The conclusion I came to was that Mormon doctrine adopts biblical terminology but defines the terms differently than orthodox Christianity does. "Grace" is one example. My bible, and orthodox Christian doctrine, declares that grace is totally undeserved favor. No one can "earn" grace. Yet, I am persuaded that Mormon doctrines teach that grace and salvation are earned.

Beyond that, the sovereignty of one creator God over all of creation, even unto the entire universe, as the Bible clearly teaches, is called into question by Mormon doctrine. Also, as I understand it, Mormon doctrine says that men can become gods just like God himself. That is very strange to me.

There is much more I could say, but in the final analysis, I see the Mormon religion relying on a great deal of extra-biblical revelation which they consider on par with the Bible, and I'm always skeptical of that.

I never assume that any group that uses the name of Christ is truly Christian. In fact, many of them are not (the Shakers come to mind). And, sadly, I'm of the mind that many who live under the belief that they are Christians are not. This is made alarmingly clear in Matthew 7:21-23.

It appears to me that Mormon followers, as a group, are moral people, remarkable in many ways for their hard work and responsibility. They are serious about their faith and do many positive, admirable things. All of this is commendable, but I do not believe they are true followers of Jesus Christ.

Herrick Kimball said...

I can think of no better investment for an inheritance than to use it to put down roots in a place where you and your family can be a family and establish a farm/homestead family economy. However, unless the rest of your family is "on board" with the agrarian vision, you may be getting into a difficult situation. I suggest that you take it one prayerful step at a time. I also suggest that you and your family read my book, "Writings of a Deliberate Agrarian." e-mail your address to me and I'll send you a complimentary copy:

It was my pleasure. I'm glad to direct people to such a wholesome and inspiring blog as yours.


I have a feeling that a great many of G.B.'s audience is Christian and they do not for a second interpret his call to humility and prayer as a call to the Mormon religion.

It is remarkable to me that a mainstream media sensation is telling the masses that he has no idea how we're going to get out of the mess we're in as a country and that we just need to humble ourselves and rely on "divine providence," as our founders did. Those founders were not Mormons.

It has been fascinating to me that many of his guests have been outspoken Christians. David Barton or Wallbuilders is one. I did hear one Mormon guest but I don't listen to the show every day.

I should point out that when I said "God bless Glenn Beck"in my essay I was not condoning his Mormonism, I meant very sincerely that I hope God will bless him with safety and wisdom and a deeper understanding of Biblical truth.

Thanks for your comment here.

Herrick Kimball said...

Some of you may be interested in reading....

David Barton's View of Glenn Beck

Diane in TX said...

If you are interested in the Amish, I think you would love this BBC documentary available on youtube titled "Trouble in Amish Paradise".

Love your blog!

Julie-Ann said...

Graceful blog moderation.

Great blog-o-zine this month. I am looking forward to reading more as you outline some way out of the "common conundrum" of the "industrial system vortex." Sadly, there are some women stuck in it too.

Jim Curley said...

Mr. Kimball

As always I enjoy your monthly update.

Regarding family hog slaughters, we raise pigs in SC and slaughter some 8-10 every year on our property. While i have posted pictures on my blog in the past, I have never documented pictorally the entire process. Maybe I will some time in the future.

Most of my boys and girls look forward to slaughter days, especially when we have friends helping and sharing in the process and proceeds.

Happy New Year!


Robert said...


Love your blog. My wife and I are trying to learn as much 'pre-industrial era wisdom/skills' as we can and are blogging about it. Hog butchering is one of those that I hope to learn some day soon. Stay tuned!

My mother in law got me a great gift for Christmas - she scrounged the first six volumes of the foxfire series. Its a great starting point.

God Bless. Robert

Anonymous said...

I look forward to the new book.
All the best to you & yours in the New Year.
Granny Miller

Anonymous said...

Mr. kimball, I greatly admire the work you have done here in these essays, Thank-you! I am a devoted reader from before the end of month blog and am writing not to comment but to ask where i might find your plans for the garden tote? Your January 2010 essay mentions that it would one day be available in your store? Just seeking a project to fill the cold northern new york winter before the maple sap starts to run. Thank-you for your time. Sincerly, Thomas

Herrick Kimball said...

Thanks again everyone for your comments here this month. Thomas—I wish I had the garden tote plans together for you. I wanted to have them done long ago but that's the case with so many different product and project ideas I have. I can't keep up with my imagination. The totes have been very useful around here and I fully intend to get the how-to information together but right now I am focusing like a laser beam on this newest book project. Maybe next January. :-(

Thanks for asking.

Anonymous said...
This was written by Dorothy Sayers in the 1940s. I think you will find it very interesting. I enjoy reading on your site and wish you well.

Anonymous said...


As a member of the LDS faith, I respectfully dis-agree with you regarding our Christianity. However, I truly appreciate what one of the earlier commenters called your "graceful blog moderation". You are truly an inspiring example of how to treat others, even those with whom you disagree. As such, a true example of a Christian. I found your blog through the Chicken butchering essays, then found it again a couple months ago, and it really took hold the second time- I started at the beginning, and read through it, in chronological order. It took me two months of evenings, and has inspired me to work harder at realizing my dreams, and aligning myself and my plans with God's will for my life. I bought the "Deliberate Agrarian" writings for myself, and upon your recommendation, several Eric Sloane books for my children (I had one years ago, did not realize he was so prolific) and some of the Sugar Creek books for my youngest son.

I have been working my way through "Deliberate Agrarian", I read no more than a chapter a day, a bit of inspiration before breakfast, and then I re-visit ones I have read previously. One I have marked and returned to many times is the one on deliberate contentment. I have always struggled with that, never being satisfied, pushing for more. But the sentance that struck me the most was "That, in most instances, He grants us gifts far beyond our genuine needs is a further manifestation of His grace (getting what you don't deserve) and mercy (not getting what you do deserve)." I don't think I have ever read a more concise explanation of grace and mercy, and will likely quote from it, the next time I am asked to speak in church.

Finally, despite our theological differences- you have inspired me to work harder at being a better man, a better husband, and a better father. Thanks- James Christsiansen

Books Dudes Will Read said...

Dear Mr. Herrick-
I came upon your blog when I was looking, of course, for a chicken plucker! Your Whizbang Machine is a wonder. After a bit of perusing, I had to follow your blog, too. Though my religious and educational beliefs are entirely different from yours, I find your viewpoint refreshing and your information relevant. So thank you for doing what you do! I respect that you homeschooled your sons. They seem to have flourished under your tutelage, and it seems to be the best system for you. I think it's unfortunate that the current economic/governmental pressures force most families into "the system." But!!! On behalf of "the system," (I've been a teacher for nearly 18 years) most of the American educators I know DO encourage children to think independently and work hard. I often do wish that I had the means to homeschool my son. It is much more difficult to "innoculate" him against the poisons of our culture when he is exposed to them every day, but I blame the negative influences more on his peers than on the teachers. So, the "tune-out" problem, in my experienc is more social and parental than a product of education. Certainly, there is still pressure for kids to compete academically with countries like China & Japan, who rely completely on rote memorization. Still, American teachers resist. So, please know, that I am not bashing home-schoolers; some are better than others at it, in my observations. But I do feel the need to defend hard-working teachers, too. We have to do a whole lot for so many who come to us with, often, little to nothing. Many parents don't put much effort into teaching. Too many have few economic or emotional resources. My choices as a parent and citizen have become more like your own, despite having come to them by a somewhat different path. I involve myself in my son's learning. And I'm starting my own agrarian lifestyle. And, again, I truly appreciate what I see here in its guidance on my journey.

Larry G. said...

Just thought you might like to see these pictures from the past. This is from CNN's website today. Picture 5 is from Aroostook county, Maine.
My wife and I have been following your website for a number of years now and really enjoy the good information and sound advice that you present. We also follow Michael Bunker and Scott Terry (I actually visited Scott and Leah Terry a few years ago when looking for land in New York. Wonderful folks.)
We recently purchased an Amish-built, off-grid house in the mountains of southwest Virginia and hope to homestead there in a few years.
God Bless.

Larry G.

Larry G. said...

Oops....forgot the link. Here it is:

Herrick Kimball said...

I'm about to post my next monthly essay and before I do I just want to say again how much I appreciate the comments, and links, and so forth that everyone has posted here this month. Your responses here have made this blog more thought provoking and worthwhile.